Case By Case


Falling Through a SkyLight Window – Property Liability

by | Mar 30, 2021 | Case Studies | 0 comments

Each case study is based on real cases that Johnson | Livingston has either successfully settled or completed with a verdict. Our success is based on the way we approach taking care of our clients, our expertise, and gathering evidence and facts.

Type of Injury 

Compound Fracture to Femur – Property Liability 


Our client who was 11, was with a friend and climbed on the roof of a nearby middle school. She stood on the skylight.  The skylight broke and she fell through, resulting in a compound fracture of her femur.


Incident Details & Facts 

The insurance company argued comparative fault because she trespassed and climbed on the roof of a building that she shouldn’t have. However, we argued that she is young and irresponsible and the big problem was that the school made it SUPER easy for kids to climb the roof the way the roof was designed. 


The school was aware of multiple people that had climbed on the roof and other serious injuries that had previously occurred. After our case was started and we went out to conduct a site inspection we learned that they had in fact reconstructed the area to eliminate the easy access.


Case Details & Why They Needed a Lawyer 

  1. The defense argued why it could not have been our client’s fault. If we had not been brought into the case, not only would the client likely not receive compensation the school wouldn’t be motivated to reconstruct the roof issue and fix it for potential future problems.


Clients Biggest Concerns Addressed About the Case 

Because you are “trespassing” it doesn’t mean you don’t have a case, you need an attorney to review the facts and be honest with you about the concerns and potentials for a case related to your specific injuries and concerns.


Case Results 

Our client had a lot of medical expenses and she was able to receive compensation that covered all her medical bills and she had some left over in her pocket as well. It turned out well for her and future children because the school was fixed. 


Side note: Her mother was killed in a car accident and she was being raised by her grandpa. This would have been very hard for him to pay and he had no means to fight this himself. Getting an attorney that works on contingency fees is what made it possible for our client to afford her medical treatment.


Key Takeaways from Case 

  1. Having an attorney that understands the ins and outs of property liability, and Utah laws can significantly influence the outcome of a case. 
  2. Attorneys that are focused on facts, and evidence and creating changes to protect other children should be willing to fight and stand for their clients even if it means suing a government entity.


What to Expect in a Consultation with Johnson | Livingston?

We take each case seriously. During your free consultation, you can count on us to listen to your story, take notes, and ask you questions about how your life has been impacted. You can also count on us to communicate in ways that are not overwhelming or to use lawyer jargon.

  • Review What Happened to You
  • Review Current Steps and Progress
  • Discuss Life Changes & Impact of Case
  • Give You a Chance to Ask Questions
Schedule a FREE Consultation Today > 


Submit a Comment